Management Turnover as Change Agent

Showing posts with label Martin Sullivan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Martin Sullivan. Show all posts

Monday, June 16, 2008

CEO Watch List - Martin Sullivan, AIG - Is Out - Update 3

Chalk up another CEO to the sub-prime credit crisis.  AIG's CEO, Martin Sullivan was forced out yesterday, Sunday June 15th, after the company's board had an emergency meeting.  Sullivan will not only give up his CEO title he is also leaving the board.  AIG immediately selected Robert Willumstad, the current chairman and well known former Citibank top executive as AIG's new CEO. Willumstad will remain chairman.   The board also selected Stephen Bollenbach, chairman of US homebuilder KB Homes and former chief executive of Hilton Hotels, as the lead director.  

The dramatic changes came shortly after powerful activist shareholders expressed concern with AIG's management.  See my previous blog for additional details on the concerns raised by activist shareholders.  Sullivan leaves the world's largerst insurer according to Reuters,
... after it suffered two quarters of record losses from risky mortgage bets and its share price more than halved over the past year.
While the latest management changes were applauded by some of the key activist shareholders. In another Reuters piece Eli Broad was quoted as stating,
"Both are proven, experienced and successful financial executives," he said in an emailed statement. "I expect that they will attract badly needed, first-rate financial and investment executives to AIG."
The real question for me and many others is whether Willumstad is the right person for the position.  While he originally contended for the top Citibank position before Charles Prince another casualty of the credit crisis was appointed head of CitiGroup his background was in consumer banking.  He is not a real insurance guy.  According to report he did have insurance companies reporting directly to him when he was Chief Operating Officer of CitiGroup but that may not be sufficient.  At a minimum expect further management changes.  The Willumstad and Bollenbach appointments will not be sufficient alone to turn the huge AIG ship around but at least it is a well-needed start.

AIG is already in the process of searching for a new CFO.  Expect more changes as Willumstad works to get a handle on all the problems facing the firm.  He has already made a formal gesture of some kind to former CEO and Chairman Maurice Greenberg who was forced out under a cloud but still remains a huge stakeholder in the firm and thorn in its back.  For some time now Greenberg has been one of AIG management's greatest critics.  According to the Washington Times,
Greenberg has been one of most outspoken of AIG's shareholders, many of whom have blamed poor management for AIG's financial troubles. In a May regulatory filing, Greenberg wrote: "AIG is in crisis."
In assessing what might be next for the firm, Hugh Son and Dan Kraut of Bloomberg quoted an analyst from  UBS AG, David Havens who said,
"AIG needs to go through some sort of process to prove to the market that it completely understands the credit risk that it faces,'' ... "Some sort of internal and perhaps external study might be necessary here.''
Watch who AIG appoints as CFO and make sure to stay up-to-date on future management changes, there are sure to be more.  Willumstad has a tough task ahead of him, besides the sub-prime credit related problems, the insurance business has been straining lately under increasing claims due to weather and natural disasters.

For more:



Monday, June 9, 2008

CEO Watch List - Martin Sullivan, AIG, Update 1

Just a month ago I put AIG's CEO Martin Sullivan on my CEO watch list.  So far, Sullivan has managed to keep his job.  According to Felix Salmon of SeekingAlpha.com the Wall Street Journal has run another story today placing new pressures on Sullivan.  According to the WSJ article by Liam Pleven and Randall Smith,
American International Group Inc.'s embattled chief executive, Martin Sullivan, is now facing mounting dissent from some of his largest shareholders.

Two days before AIG's May 14 annual meeting, three major shareholders who effectively controlled more than 100 million shares -- about 4% of the company's stock at the time -- sent a blistering letter to the company's board....

... people familiar with the board say Mr. Sullivan needs to turn things around fast. Amid widespread turmoil in the credit markets, AIG has reported two consecutive record quarterly losses totaling $13 billion -- almost as much as the firm made all of 2006 -- and last month raised $20 billion to bolster its finances, a remarkable reversal for an insurer long prized by investors for its business savvy.
The added pressure of the WSJ article definitely turned the screw a bit more on Sullivan's chances to survive as CEO.  Keep a close eye on AIG and any new business decisions Sullivan and/or the company makes.

Friday, May 16, 2008

Recommended Reading - Haunting G.E. and A.I.G.

Yesterday Jeffrey Cane wrote a clever little piece in Portfolio.com on G.E. and A.I.G's former CEOs who have managed recently to give their predecessors further heartburn as they struggle with their current positions.  At a minimum, the piece is worth a good chuckle.  Check it out.

Friday, May 9, 2008

CEO Watch - Martin Sullivan, AIG

Back in early February I wondered if AIG's CEO, Martin Sullivan, might have been at risk for his job.  At the time, the company's auditor Pricewaterhouse Coopers LLC, found "material weakness" in AIG's accounting for credit-default swap contracts that translated into a huge drop in the company's stock. Despite my blog post, I did not believe Sullivan should have been added to my CEO Watch list.  Today, I am not so sure.  

AIG's surprise announcement earlier today that it posted a $7.8 billion first-quarter loss has put Sullivan in a really difficult spot.  According to a story by Colin Barr for Forbes,
AIG (AIG, Fortune 500) shares tumbled 9% Friday after the insurance giant posted a $7.8 billion first-quarter loss that was driven by another round of mark-to-market writedowns of mortgage-related positions. AIG said the latest quarter included a $5.9 billion pretax writedown of the value of the credit default swap portfolio held by its AIG Financial Products unit, and a $3.6 billion impairment of its mortgage-backed securities holdings.
The spin is already on.  Will shareholders and board members stay quiet as AIG (Sullivan) seems blind sided a second time in a row?  We will just have to wait and see.  For now, Sullivan stays on my CEO watch list.  Keep a close eye on AIG and PR that comes from the firm.

For more:


Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Is AIG's CEO, Martin Sullivan in Trouble?

Is AIG's AIG (NYSE) CEO, Martin Sullivan at risk to lose his job? Yesterday's surprise announcement (see 8k filing) that its auditor, Pricewaterhouse Coopers LLC, found "material weakness" in AIG's accounting for credit-default swap contracts translated into a huge drop in the company's stock. According to a story by Hugh Son and Jesse Westbrook in today's Bloomberg doubts are being raised by some concerning Sullivan's leadership.
"It is incomprehensible that yet once again, this company, its board, its CEO and CFO, and its independent auditors are saying the company doesn't have adequate controls," said Lynn Turner, former chief accountant at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and now on the board of Guidance Software Inc. and the Colorado Public Employees' Retirement Association. "These people should all be held accountable."
The speculation on Sullivan's status at AIG seems premature for the moment. We will just have to wait and see. Stay tuned.

For more:

Portfolio.com
Reuters